If this, then that
Grade 6 · Puzzles and reasoning
The rule "if it rains, then the grass is wet" tells what happens when it rains. It says nothing about other days. So ask: does the rule really tell me this, or could something else have happened? If you can't be sure, the answer is that we can't tell.
Words to know
- rule
- A sentence that says what always happens. If this, then that.
- first part
- The part after if. In "if it rains, then the grass is wet" it is "it rains".
- second part
- The part after then. Here it is "the grass is wet".
- for sure
- With no doubt at all.
- can't tell
- It might be true, or it might not. The rule does not say.
Level 1 · The first part is true
You are told the first part is true. Then the rule says the second part happens too.
Here's how it works
The rule: if Ravi is in the pool, then Ravi is wet. Ravi is in the pool. What do we know for sure?
- We can't tell if Ravi is wet.
- Ravi is not wet.
- Ravi is wet.
- Ravi is in the pool, so the rule says Ravi is wet.
Level 2 · The second part is not true
Now the second part did not happen. If the first part were true it would have, so the first part is not true.
Here's how it works
The rule: if it is snowing, then it is cold outside. It is not cold outside. What do we know for sure?
- It is snowing.
- It is not snowing.
- We can't tell if it is snowing.
- If it is snowing, then it is cold outside. But it is not cold outside.
- So it is not snowing.
Level 3 · The second part is true: can we tell?
Now the second part is true, but something else could have made it happen. A pet with four legs could be a cat, so we can't tell.
Here's how it works
The rule: if the pet is a dog, then the pet has four legs. The pet has four legs. What do we know for sure?
- The pet is a dog.
- The pet is not a dog.
- We can't tell if the pet is a dog.
- The rule says what happens if the pet is a dog. Something else could make it so that the pet has four legs.
- So we can't tell if the pet is a dog.
Level 4 · The first part is not true: can we tell?
Now the first part is not true, and the rule says nothing about that. So we can't tell about the second part.
Here's how it works
The rule: if it is raining, then the grass is wet. It is not raining. What do we know for sure?
- The grass is not wet.
- We can't tell if the grass is wet.
- The grass is wet.
- The rule only says what happens if it is raining. It says nothing when it is not raining.
- So we can't tell if the grass is wet.
Level 5 · Which if-then sentences must be true?
The rule is true, and so is "if not the second part, then not the first". Swapping the two parts, or putting not into both parts, does not have to be true.
Here's how it works
The rule: if Lucy is in the pool, then Lucy is wet. Which of these must be true? Choose every one.
Answer: If Lucy is not wet, then Lucy is not in the pool. and If Lucy is in the pool, then Lucy is wet.
- If Lucy is not wet, then it can't be that Lucy is in the pool: so Lucy is not in the pool.
- Turning the rule round, or putting not into both parts, doesn't have to be true.
With an account, NumZing gives your kid short practice on this skill, starting where they are, and tells you what to do next.
For grown-ups: how to explain it
If-then rules
“If it rains, the grass is wet” tells us what happens when it rains. Wet grass doesn't prove it rained, and no rain doesn't prove the grass is dry. Dry grass does prove it didn't rain.
Kids turn the rule round, or put “not” into both parts, because both sound like the same rule.
Show it like this
If a shape is a square, it has four corners. A shape with four corners might be a rectangle.
5 minutes at home
Say an if-then rule about home (“if the oven is on, the kitchen is warm”) and ask what you know when the kitchen is warm, or not warm.
Check it worked: If it is snowing, it is cold. It is cold. Is it snowing?