Truth-tellers and fibbers
Grade 4 · Puzzles and reasoning
Each person always tells the truth or always lies. A fibber's words are never true. Pretend a person is a truth-teller and check every sentence. If something does not fit, try them as a fibber.
Words to know
- truth-teller
- Someone who always says true things.
- fibber
- Someone who always says things that are not true.
- at least one
- One or more.
- exactly one
- One, and no more.
- the same kind
- Both truth-tellers, or both fibbers.
Level 1 · Check a saying against a fact
Check what the person says against what is true. If it matches, they are a truth-teller; if not, they are a fibber.
Here's how it works
Each one is a truth-teller, who always tells the truth, or a fibber, who always lies. Amara says, “My scarf is red.” Amara's scarf is yellow. What is Amara?
- Truth-teller
- Fibber
- Amara said red, and the scarf is yellow.
- That is not true, so Amara is a fibber.
Level 2 · When you know the other one
You already know what one person is. Check if the saying about them is true, and that tells you what the speaker is.
Here's how it works
Each one is a truth-teller, who always tells the truth, or a fibber, who always lies. Ella is a fibber. Ana says, “Ella is a truth-teller.” What is Ana?
- Truth-teller
- Fibber
- Ella is a fibber, so “Ella is a truth-teller.” is not true.
- So Ana is a fibber.
Level 3 · One saying, two people
Try the speaker as a truth-teller, then as a fibber, and keep the way that fits. Then the saying tells you what the other person is.
Here's how it works
Each one is a truth-teller, who always tells the truth, or a fibber, who always lies. Omar and Ana are playing. Omar says, “At least one of us is a fibber.” What is Ana?
- Truth-teller
- Fibber
- Only one way fits every sentence: Omar is a truth-teller, Ana is a fibber.
- So Ana is a fibber.
Level 4 · Two sayings, two people
Both people speak, so there are 4 ways they could be. Try each, and keep the way where every saying fits.
Here's how it works
Each one is a truth-teller, who always tells the truth, or a fibber, who always lies. Kofi and Lucy are playing. Kofi says, “We are all fibbers.” Lucy says, “Kofi and I are not the same kind.” What is Lucy?
- Truth-teller
- Fibber
- Only one way fits every sentence: Kofi is a fibber, Lucy is a truth-teller.
- So Lucy is a truth-teller.
Level 5 · Three people: who fibs?
Start with the person you can be surest of. Then try the others, and keep the way where every saying fits.
Here's how it works
Each one is a truth-teller, who always tells the truth, or a fibber, who always lies. Noah, Diego and Lucy are playing. Noah says, “We are all fibbers.” Lucy says, “Noah is a truth-teller.” Who is a fibber? Choose every one.
Answer: Noah and Lucy
- Only one way fits every sentence: Noah is a fibber, Diego is a truth-teller, Lucy is a fibber.
- The fibbers: Noah, Lucy.
With an account, NumZing gives your kid short practice on this skill, starting where they are, and tells you what to do next.
For grown-ups: how to explain it
Truth-tellers and fibbers
Each person always tells the truth or always lies. Try each one as a truth-teller, then as a fibber, and keep the way where every sentence fits.
Kids believe whatever is said. A fibber's words are false, which is the clue.
Show it like this
Ava says “We are both fibbers.” A truth-teller can't say that, so Ava fibs, and since it's false, Ben tells the truth.
5 minutes at home
Play a round where one of you always lies. Ask questions and work out who the fibber is.
Check it worked: Kim is a truth-teller. Lou says “Kim is a fibber.” What is Lou?